What distinguishes a project manager from a business analyst? These days, particularly for individuals considering career transitions, it seems that this is the most frequently stated concern. The majority of people are perplexed by their competing positions and duties. Business analytics vs project management are very similar career choices, yet some differences exist.
While launching a new project, one strategy to minimize this ambiguity is to examine the position description of a project manager and a business analyst. Suppose you want to learn the difference between business analyst and project manager. In that case, we suggest you go for Project Management certification preparation program.
Project Management vs Business Analyst: Comparison Table
The table given below will give you a good idea about business analyst versus project manager roles and responsibilities:
| Parameter | Business Analyst | Project Manager |
|---|
| Examining the task | Analyze the business opportunities | Analyze the needs of the project |
| Dealing with stakeholders | Organizing and ranking business requirements with stakeholder input | Organizing and ranking business requirements with stakeholder input |
| Creating a project flowchart | Creating a project plan for how the entire project will be executed including a project schedule | Laying together a project schedule and a plan for how the job will be done |
| Handling test cases | Reviews test results | Distributes the test cases |
| Relation with team members | Works with the team members | Closes any communication gap in the team |
| Influencing | Meet business userās expectations | Manage stakeholderās expectations |
| Perspectives | Go through the strategy of process level | Go through the strategy at organizational level |
| Time management | Make sure that the project is delivered on time | Manage the project schedule of the team |
| Critical thinking | Change any analytical data into decisions | Control any major changes and manage the scope. |
Difference Between Project Management and Business Analyst
Here we talk a little more about the difference between business analysis and project management:
1. Project Management vs. Business Analyst: Examining the Task
Business analysts conduct studies to establish whether possible business ideas are financially viable options. They usually advise management on how to explore new opportunities best and consider the marketing opportunity's cost, the person or entity giving it, and how it can affect their business's revenues and values.
Project managers frequently do cost, labor, material, and scope analyses on their projects. They also assist in determining if a company's current resources can adequately support a project or whether additional ones are required.
2. Project Management vs. Business Analyst: Dealing with Stakeholders
A business analyst collects requirements from various stakeholders while comprehending the business cases. A business analyst also examines those needs and verifies no conflicts. They ask for clarification from stakeholders if there are unclear or ambiguous requirements.
On the other hand, a project manager is in close contact with the project board, the steering committee, and the program manager. They are constantly updating them about the progress made in the project at every step.
3. Project Management vs. Business Analyst: Creating a Project Flowchart
The Business Analyst goes into considerable detail while preparing the business requirements. They divide out the job among the developers after deconstructing the procedure.
On the other hand, the project manager creates a communication calendar for developers and stakeholders and works on a risk management strategy to mitigate all impending project hazards. The project plan is then implemented after the business analyst and project manager have collected the ideas and viewpoints.
4. Project Management vs. Business Analyst: Handling Test Cases
Once the project has been created, it goes through a control phase. In this phase, the project manager's job is to take note of all the test cases. They then distribute them and finally complete the project. After this, the final review is done by the business analyst.
The business analyst reviews all the test results and finds out any kinds of bugs. They find the solution to any kinds of bugs found in the project and also suggest any improvements that are needed. These could include reviews, customer feedback, output rate, financial reports, company policies, and losses or gains.
5. Project Management vs. Business Analyst: Relation with Team Members
The business analyst works with all the participants of the team. Once they gather all the necessary information for the project, they translate the research into understandable terms for the team members. During the project's lifecycle, the business analyst thoroughly manages the internal team involved in the project.
Project managers enhance the direct relationship between the production and development teams and management staff. Project managers play a critical role as intermediary leaders in helping team members and management agree on a project's criteria, objectives, and goals.
6. Project Management vs. Business Analyst: Influencing
A business analyst conducts workshops and proper research to understand the needs of the end users. Once they have a good idea of what the users are looking for, they build the project on that. A business analyst manages expectations by guaranteeing that developers know what is expected of them and clients get a complete product that meets their needs.
Stakeholder communication and management are the sole provinces of the project managers. Before the program begins, they must ensure "project success" is precisely defined. They must also take care to avoid keeping stakeholders in the dark for an extended period of time. Finally, while engaging with project stakeholders, they should make things straightforward.
7. Project Management vs. Business Analyst: Perspectives
It is the responsibility of the business analyst to go through the project at the process level. At this phase of the project, these individuals understand the working of the process and make any necessary changes to increase efficiency.
The project manager on the other hand, goes through the project at an organizational level. They appraise growth of the project, the individuals involved and the work environment of the entity.
8. Project Management vs. Business Analyst: Time Management
The business analyst is responsible for ensuring the project is delivered on time. These individuals work in close relation with their team members and make sure that the project adheres to the deadline that has been provided.
The project manager on the other hand supervises smooth functioning of the project. They are also in close contact with the stakeholders keeping them updated about the progress made in the project.
9. Project Management vs. Business Analyst: Critical Thinking
The necessary research for the project is made by the business analyst. Any kind of data that they collect for the project is then communicated with the team. The business analyst takes any kind of necessary decision regarding the information that has been collected.
In case there are any major necessary changes in the project, it is the responsibility of the project manager to supervise that. These individuals coordinate the changes within the team and with the stakeholders.
To better understand the roles of business analysts and project managers, the Project Management professional preparation course is an excellent course.
Top Cities where Knowledgehut Conduct Project Management Certification Training Course Online
How are they Similar?
The project management vs business analyst is clear from the points stated above. However, dependent on the organization's business module, both positions are still common. Both BA and PM have a part to play in the expansion of the businesses. While business analysts are lone contributors to the assigned project, project managers take on leadership duties. Project managers routinely take on responsibility as soon as the products they developed with their team are sold and begin to benefit the company.
1. Domain
The three areas that project management job addresses are people, processes, and the business environment (these are the three domains defined by PMI). Business analysts must operate inside these domains as well.
2. Interpersonal Skills
Both professions require a wide range of interpersonal abilities:
- Leadership skills
- Communication skills
- Delegating
Although each job requires a different output, similar skill sets are still necessary. Like a senior project manager, a senior business analyst will likely take on more leadership and strategic stakeholder interaction.
3. Scheduling Meetings
Project managers and business analysts both lead meetings. The primary abilities of workshop facilitators remain the same, despite the slightly diverse meeting kinds, stakeholders, and outcomes.
One of the critical business analysis tasks is workshop facilitation, with over 75% of members using it as their primary method for identifying business needs and carrying out the work necessary. According to observations, project managers conduct a variety of meetings that call for the same leadership capabilities but involve fewer workshops:
- Ability to vocally communicate in an organized format
- Presentation expertise (designing a session and running it)
- Techniques for scheduling meetings to keep things on schedule
- Designing a schedule
- Creating meeting minutes and recording the outcomes of a meeting
4. Salaries
The business analyst vs project manager salary is also quite similar. The nationwide average salaries for project managers and business analysts also vary marginally. Project managers make an average annual pay of $77,633 compared to business analysts, who receive an average yearly salary of $77,154.
Despite their ability to find chances in various firms, both individuals typically work full-time in an office environment. The project management vs business analyst salary is a point that you must consider when choosing a career path.
You can learn in-depth about the similarities between project management and business analysis by enrolling in online PRINCE2 Foundation and Practitioner course.
What Should You Choose Between Project Management vs Business Analyst?
A business analyst or project manager, which is better, is a very common question for anyone who is choosing a career path. Many professionals work for different companies in which they have two or more roles to play. These could frequently occur with BA and PM as well. Both are decision-makers and leaders. As a consequence, they may shape themselves to compete in either position.
BA and PM jobs would be consolidated and assigned as one resource if any business felt the need to maintain both roles, chose to reduce resource costs, or believed the project was too small to allocate both resources. The professions of Business Analyst and Project Manager may need to be changed if they keep adapting to the firm's needs. Employers typically seek out professionals who can manage a range of duties, which may be helpful for them.
Project managers have one advantage over business analysts when we are talking about changing careers because project managers frequently have both managerial and technical skills. In contrast, business analysts typically have business skills and are more product-focused, even though they may contribute to project-related tasks. Although the overlap in competencies, the mindset is different.
In the present state of business, business analysts may not have access to senior business analyst positions because many firms do not retain that vertical. Hence, if the BA were to consider changing careers, it would be more realistic for them to become involved in project management. Based on the organizational ladder, it is common to see project managers try switching to a business analyst career. If you are confused between project management or business analytics, the KnowledgeHut Project Management Online Training will give you a proper idea of the job roles and help you make a clear decision. It helps you understand the role of business analyst in project management.
Before you choose between the two, you need to understand the relationship between project manager and business analyst. The above job roles give you some idea of what each role entails. If you are wondering about a business analyst vs project manager career path, you must consider what suits your liking. Here we will discuss some more important aspects of these two job roles:
Unleash your team's potential with agile project management certifications. Embrace change and achieve faster results.
Skills Needed by Project Managers
To have a successful project manager career, one must either have or work on the following skills:
- Organization Skills: Project managers must have the proper organizational skills to keep things organized during the manufacturing process. A manager with managerial skills can better comprehend a project's requirements and ensure it moves toward its intended result.
- Negotiation Skills: Project managers typically renegotiate budgets or material needs and act as a point of contact for teams and leaders. A project manager skilled in negotiation can get a consensus on adjustments.
- Leadership Skills: Project managers frequently serve in a leadership capacity for teams of experts. As a result, effective project managers routinely put their leadership abilities, such as tolerance, empathy, communication, collaboration, honesty, and mentorship, into practice.
Skills Required by a Business Analyst
Here we talk about the skills one must have to become a successful business analyst:
- Sales Skills: Successful business analysts are acquainted with the fundamentals of sales and marketing and are skilled at enhancing products and procedures to improve customer service. Business analysts can find strengths in a business model and forecast sales trends using sales skills.
- Data Analysis Skills: Data, tracking charts, measuring specific metrics, and using data to enhance businesses or draw in new clients are all abilities that business analysts typically possess.
- Analysis Skills: A substantial percentage of their time is spent analyzing firms and business requirements. Strong analytical abilities are often needed, including communication and critical thinking. Analysts can better articulate their findings and provide accurate, workable analyses using these skills.
Often there arises a question of whether a project manager is in charge of a business analyst. Business analysts seconded to the team will function as team members and contribute their specialized expertise to the project just as any other subject matter expert would. Based on the hierarchy chart, the project manager will be "in control" of the BA.
Project managers and business analysts should always be delivery partners, in my personal experience. Much like working with a business change manager, it is much simpler to truly understand what the project is intended to provide and ensure that outcome is realized the better the BA and PM work together.
Conclusion
We can conclude after reading the article that there are some differences between business analyst and project manager, in addition to producing bug-free code and contributing to good software, but also resolve issues and exceed client expectations. These goals are allocated to project managers and business analysts. Generally, a project manager focuses on the project as a set of activities, establishes baselines, engages with the development team, and handles project-related challenges.
On the other hand, a business analyst is focused on the final product, studies market issues, and suggests a technical solution. As a result, while a business analyst's and a project manager's duties and responsibilities differ in a company, they are both essential to a project's success. Ace your PMP exam on the first attempt by enrolling in KnowledgeHut's project management professional certification programs.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Which is better: Project Manager or Business Analyst?
This article describes the roles and responsibilities for each position in detail. It will help you make a well-informed decision according to your liking and skills.
2. Can a Business Analyst become a Project Manager?
Yes, a business analyst can become a project manager. Since there are many similarities between the job roles, it is a fairly common career choice.
3. Can a Business Analyst become a CEO?
Even though the job role of a CEO is way more complex than a business analyst, yes, a business analyst can become a CEO.
4. What is the next career step after Project Manager?
Once you have become a project manager, there are many other career options that you can consider:
- Program Manager
- Management consultant
- Portfolio manager
5. What are the main differences between Project managers and Business analysts?
Project managers supervise the entire process of building any project. They also communicate with the stakeholders. In contrast, a business analyst conducts workshops and sits with the team to create the project.
